Many places sound like a dream retirement destination—but in reality, they’re too expensive, overcrowded, or just not as great as advertised. Whether it’s high taxes, cost of living, or hidden downsides, these overrated retirement spots might not be the paradise you expect.
If you’re looking for a better quality of life, affordability, and a stress-free retirement, here’s where NOT to retire—and where you should consider instead.
1. Miami, Florida
🔻 Why It’s Overrated:
- Sky-high cost of living—Miami is no longer an affordable retirement destination.
- Overcrowded beaches and traffic nightmares year-round.
- Hurricane risk and rising insurance costs.
✅ Better Alternative: Naples, FL – Quieter, safer, and has a strong retirement community.
2. Los Angeles, California
🔻 Why It’s Overrated:
- One of the most expensive cities in the U.S.—housing, food, and taxes are brutal.
- Traffic congestion makes daily life stressful.
- State income tax is high, which eats into retirement savings.
✅ Better Alternative: San Luis Obispo, CA – Milder climate, less traffic, and more affordable than LA.
3. Honolulu, Hawaii
🔻 Why It’s Overrated:
- Cost of living is nearly double the national average—everything is imported.
- Tourism congestion makes everyday life difficult.
- Expensive flights to visit family on the mainland.
✅ Better Alternative: Hilo, HI – More affordable than Honolulu, with beautiful scenery and a laid-back vibe.
4. New York City, New York
🔻 Why It’s Overrated:
- Sky-high rent and property taxes make it unaffordable for most retirees.
- Harsh winters and crowded streets can be overwhelming.
- Not great for fixed-income living due to unpredictable expenses.
✅ Better Alternative: Saratoga Springs, NY – More peaceful, with good healthcare and a lower cost of living.
5. San Francisco, California
🔻 Why It’s Overrated:
- One of the most expensive cities in the world.
- High crime in certain areas and a growing homelessness crisis.
- Severe tax burden on retirees.
✅ Better Alternative: Santa Rosa, CA – Offers a milder climate and is more affordable than San Francisco.
6. Phoenix, Arizona
🔻 Why It’s Overrated:
- Brutally hot summers with 115°F+ temperatures make outdoor activities tough.
- Water shortages could become a major issue.
- Overcrowded with retirees, leading to higher demand for healthcare services.
✅ Better Alternative: Prescott, AZ – Milder temperatures and a charming small-town feel.
7. Las Vegas, Nevada
🔻 Why It’s Overrated:
- Extreme heat makes it unpleasant for much of the year.
- The Strip loses its appeal fast if you’re not into gambling or nightlife.
- Healthcare options are limited compared to other major cities.
✅ Better Alternative: Reno, NV – Cooler climate, lower cost of living, and plenty of outdoor activities.
8. Austin, Texas
🔻 Why It’s Overrated:
- Exploding population growth has made Austin expensive and crowded.
- Housing prices have skyrocketed, making it harder for retirees to afford.
- Hot, humid summers can be miserable.
✅ Better Alternative: Fredericksburg, TX – A charming, quieter town with a lower cost of living.
9. Charleston, South Carolina
🔻 Why It’s Overrated:
- Frequent hurricanes and flooding can lead to costly damages.
- Tourist crowds make everyday life busy.
- Housing costs have risen dramatically.
✅ Better Alternative: Greenville, SC – Milder weather, great healthcare, and lower costs.
10. Portland, Oregon
🔻 Why It’s Overrated:
- Long, gray winters with endless rain.
- Cost of living is rising quickly, especially housing.
- State income taxes take a chunk out of retirement savings.
✅ Better Alternative: Bend, OR – More sun, lower crime, and better outdoor opportunities.
11. Washington, D.C.
🔻 Why It’s Overrated:
- One of the most expensive cities for rent and taxes.
- Traffic is a nightmare, and public transit isn’t always reliable.
- Not a retiree-friendly pace of life.
✅ Better Alternative: Asheville, NC – Lower cost of living, scenic views, and a relaxed atmosphere.
12. Boulder, Colorado
🔻 Why It’s Overrated:
- Ridiculously high cost of living, even compared to Denver.
- Harsh winters can be tough for retirees.
- Housing prices make it unrealistic for most people on a fixed income.
✅ Better Alternative: Fort Collins, CO – Still beautiful but much more affordable.
13. Naples, Florida
🔻 Why It’s Overrated:
- Overcrowded with seasonal tourists.
- One of the most expensive areas in Florida.
- Hurricane risk and high insurance costs.
✅ Better Alternative: Sarasota, FL – Still beachy but more affordable.
Read More: 10 Financial ‘Rules’ That Are Outdated in Today’s Economy
14. Santa Fe, New Mexico
🔻 Why It’s Overrated:
- Cost of living is much higher than expected.
- Not as many healthcare options as larger cities.
- Harsh winters despite being in the Southwest.
✅ Better Alternative: Las Cruces, NM – Lower costs, better weather, and still offers great culture.
Read More: The 10 Most Overhyped Investment Strategies (and What Works Instead)
15. Myrtle Beach, South Carolina
🔻 Why It’s Overrated:
- Tourists make life hectic for much of the year.
- High humidity and hurricane risks.
- Healthcare system struggles to keep up with the retiree demand.
✅ Better Alternative: Bluffton, SC – Close to the beach but quieter and more affordable.
Read More: The 10 Most Common Ways People Underestimate Retirement Costs
