11 States with the Most Surprising Favorite Pizza Toppings

Pizza is a beloved dish across the United States, with each state having its own preferences when it comes to toppings. A recent survey conducted by Tabasco Brand revealed that many Americans are quite set in their ways, often sticking to the same favorite toppings they’ve loved since childhood. This survey also highlighted some intriguing state-by-state preferences.

While some toppings are universally adored, others are more regionally popular. Here are 11 states with the most surprising favorite pizza toppings according to the survey.

11. Massachusetts: Veggie Delight

pizza with green and red bell pepper and cheese on brown wooden table
Photo by Laure Noverraz

Massachusetts stands out with its preference for veggie pizza.

This New England state is the only one to favor the veggie option, which includes toppings like green peppers, onions, olives, and mushrooms. It seems that Massachusetts residents prefer a lighter, plant-based approach to their pizzas.

10. North Dakota: Pepperoni and Supreme Tie

Fresh pepperoni pizza being sliced, highlighting delicious cheese and toppings.
Photo by Alejandro Aznar

North Dakota couldn’t choose between two classics.

In this state, pepperoni and supreme pizzas are equally loved. This dual preference highlights the residents’ appreciation for both simplicity and a variety of flavors on their pizza.

9. Iowa: Meat Lover’s and Supreme Combo

Appetizing meat-loaded pizza with shredded cheese, served on a wooden table for a perfect meal.
Photo by Pedro Furtado

Iowa’s residents are all about hearty flavors.

The state ties between meat lover’s and supreme pizzas, showcasing a preference for pizzas loaded with both meat and a variety of toppings. This choice reflects a love for robust and satisfying meals.

8. Hawaii: Supreme with a Spicy Twist

Italian Garlic Supreme, Round Table Pizza, Hilton Hawaiian Village, Honolulu
Openverse

Hawaii favors supreme pizzas but with an added kick.

More than 50% of Hawaiian residents enjoy adding spice to their supreme pizzas, indicating a preference for bold flavors that match the vibrant island lifestyle.

7. Texas: Pepperoni with a Spicy Flair

a pepperoni pizza on a plate with a spatula
Photo by Parker Hilton

In Texas, pepperoni reigns supreme, but with a spicy twist.

Texans love their pepperoni pizzas, and many add a spicy element like Tabasco sauce, reflecting the state’s penchant for fiery flavors in their cuisine.

6. Michigan: Meat Lover’s with a Classic Touch

Michigan Meatlover Pizza
Reddit: justkeptfading

Michigan residents prefer meat lover’s pizzas without extra spice.

Unlike some other states, Michigan shuns the addition of spice, favoring the traditional, hearty meat toppings without any fiery enhancements.

5. California: Pepperoni with a Spicy Kick

Spicy Pepperoni Pizza Los Angeles
Reddit: FatMoFoSho

Californians love their pepperoni with a hint of heat.

Much like Texas, California residents often add spicy sauces to their pepperoni pizzas, embracing a fusion of classic and bold flavors.

4. New Mexico: Spicy Pepperoni Preference

Pepperoni pizza with green chilis
Reddit: zaj89

New Mexico also adds a spicy twist to their pepperoni pizzas.

With a majority of residents favoring spice, New Mexicans enhance their pepperoni pizzas with hot sauces, reflecting the state’s love for fiery cuisine.

3. South Dakota: Pepperoni and Supreme Tie

Supreme Pizza in box
Reddit: r/Pizza

South Dakota shares a similar taste with its northern neighbor.

The state equally loves pepperoni and supreme pizzas, showcasing a balanced appreciation for both simplicity and a variety of toppings.

2. Louisiana: Meat Lover’s Paradise

Meatlovers pizza at Arthur's
Openverse

Louisiana residents have a strong preference for meat lover’s pizzas.

This choice aligns with the state’s rich culinary tradition, where hearty, meat-filled dishes are a staple of the local cuisine.

1. New York: The Pepperoni Capital

New York Pizza Parlor
Openverse

New York stays true to its classic pizza roots with pepperoni.

As a state known for its iconic pizza culture, it’s no surprise that New Yorkers favor the traditional pepperoni topping, keeping their pizza choices classic and timeless.

Read More:

About the Writer

Jenny Milam

The Latest

A telescope gazes at a stunning starry night sky showcasing the Milky Way.
9 Reasons Science Is Now Taking UFOs Seriously
woman in pink jacket lying on gray couch
10 Greek Mythology Words You Use Every Day
Three friends toasting with rosé wine glasses over a wooden table indoors.
9 Surprising Truths About Rosé Wine Colors
a stack of tea cups sitting on top of a saucer
10 Things Victorians Considered the Height of Luxury
Close-up of man shaving with razor
9 Expert Tips for a Smooth, Nick-Free Shave