20 Foods We Tried Because of the Hype and Actually Kept Buying

We have all been influenced at the grocery store.

Sometimes a product keeps appearing online until curiosity finally wins. Sometimes a friend will not stop talking about it. And sometimes we buy the thing everyone supposedly loves just to find out whether it could possibly be that good.

Plenty of hyped foods disappoint us. These are the ones that somehow made it from “we have to try this” to “we need another one.”

20. Chili Crisp

Spicy Chili Crisp
Openverse

For a while, it seemed like everyone was putting chili crisp on everything.

Then we tried it and understood the problem. The combination of heat, crunch, oil, and savory flavor makes eggs, noodles, rice, dumplings, vegetables, and leftovers much harder to leave alone.

19. Hot Honey

hot honey
Openverse

Drizzling spicy honey over pizza sounded like one of those trends we would try once.

Now the bottle keeps finding new jobs. It works on fried chicken, biscuits, cheese, roasted vegetables, sandwiches, and anything else that benefits from a little sweetness and heat.

18. Greek Yogurt

a glass bowl filled with cream on top of a table
Photo by Jana Ohajdova

Greek yogurt spent years being promoted as the answer to practically everything.

We may not use it for everything, but it has earned a permanent place in the refrigerator. It handles breakfast, dips, sauces, marinades, and the job normally assigned to sour cream.

17. Air-Fryer Chicken Chunks

fried food on brown wooden chopping board
Photo by Stu Moffat

The internet has strong opinions about which frozen chicken tastes most like the drive-thru version.

We bought a bag to investigate and discovered something even more useful: dinner. Crispy chicken chunks can become wraps, salads, sandwiches, rice bowls, or an emergency plate with several dipping sauces.

16. Everything Bagel Seasoning

Trader Joe's Everything but the Bagel Seasoning
Trader Joe’s

At first, putting bagel toppings into a shaker seemed almost too obvious.

Then we started sprinkling them over eggs, avocado toast, vegetables, cottage cheese, dips, and potatoes. The bottle rarely gets the chance to sit untouched for long.

15. Oat Milk

blue and white carton box on gray marble table
Photo by Leon Seibert

Oat milk arrived with enough enthusiasm to make some of us suspicious.

But its creamy texture made it particularly easy to keep around for coffee, cereal, smoothies, and cooking. Even people who never intended to give up dairy found themselves buying another carton.

14. Frozen Soup Dumplings

a bowl of dumplings with a sprig of parsley
Photo by David Foodphototasty

Restaurant-style soup dumplings from the freezer sounded almost too good to be true.

They are not quite the same as sitting down at a great dumpling restaurant, but they are remarkably satisfying for something ready in minutes. Once we discovered how easy they were, the freezer started feeling incomplete without them.

13. Burrata

sliced fruit on white ceramic plate
Photo by Sebastian Coman Photography

For a while, burrata appeared on every restaurant menu and social media feed.

We finally bought some and learned that a ball of cheese filled with cream does not require much marketing. Add tomatoes, bread, olive oil, or fruit, and suddenly we understand why everyone was making such a fuss.

12. Frozen Hash Brown Patties

a white plate topped with fried eggs and toast
Photo by David Trinks

The humble hash brown became an internet obsession all over again.

The air fryer helped. So did the realization that a crispy potato patty can hold eggs, avocado, cheese, or almost anything else we normally put on toast.

11. Sparkling Water

clear glass bottle with lemon juice
Photo by Mineragua Sparkling Water

There was a time when flavored sparkling water seemed like something people were pretending to enjoy.

Then we found the flavors we actually liked. A cold can gives us something more interesting than plain water without turning every drink into a major event.

10. Fancy Tinned Fish

person holding clear glass jar with yellow powder
Photo by Ignat Kushnarev

Tinned fish went from old-fashioned pantry food to a full-blown aesthetic.

The beautiful packaging got our attention, but the convenience kept us interested. Good sardines, mussels, trout, and tuna can become lunch with little more than bread, crackers, or a simple salad.

9. Sourdough Bread

sliced bread on brown wooden chopping board
Photo by Tommaso Urli

The sourdough craze convinced thousands of people to start naming jars of starter.

We may not have kept baking it ourselves, but we did keep buying the bread. A good loaf can improve toast, sandwiches, soup, eggs, and the experience of standing at the counter eating bread with butter.

8. Cottage Cheese

white round food on gray tray
Photo by Zoe Richardson

Cottage cheese made one of the most surprising comebacks in the grocery store.

We watched people blend it into sauces, put it on toast, and turn it into high-protein versions of almost everything. Not every viral recipe stayed with us, but the container itself somehow did.

7. Korean Frozen Dumplings

brown bread on black tray
Photo by Portuguese Gravity

One bag led to another.

Korean-style mandu became a freezer staple because they can be pan-fried, steamed, or added to a larger meal in minutes. The hype introduced us. The convenience kept them on the shopping list.

6. Sea Salt Flakes

pink powder on black frying pan
Photo by Anastasia Zhenina

Paying extra for a box of unusually shaped salt seemed a little ridiculous.

Then we sprinkled it over chocolate chip cookies, tomatoes, eggs, roasted vegetables, and buttered bread. A pinch at the end can make simple food feel far more finished.

5. Avocado Toast

green and brown vegetable on white ceramic plate
Photo by Doug Bagg

Yes, we heard all the jokes.

We also kept buying avocados. Toast topped with avocado can become breakfast, lunch, or the base for eggs, tomatoes, feta, chili crisp, and whatever else needs using up.

4. Cold Brew Coffee

black and white Cold Brew coffee bottle
Photo by Joseph Gonzalez

Cold brew was supposed to be a trend.

Instead, entire refrigerator sections appeared and stayed. Its smooth flavor and grab-and-go convenience turned plenty of curious shoppers into people who now consider a bottle essential summer equipment.

3. Frozen Croissants

a close up of a number of doughs on a tray
Photo by Jhunelle Francis Sardido

Social media made bake-at-home croissants look suspiciously effortless.

For once, the reality was almost as appealing. Pulling warm, flaky pastries from the oven without making laminated dough from scratch is exactly the kind of shortcut we are willing to keep buying.

2. The Trader Joe’s Product Everyone Wouldn’t Stop Talking About

trader joe's foods
Openverse

Sometimes we try a product because avoiding it has become more difficult than buying it.

The specific item changes, but the pattern does not. Someone recommends it, social media piles on, and eventually we make the trip to see what all the fuss is about. Occasionally, the internet gets one completely right.

1. The Aldi Find We Went Back to Buy Again

aldi store
Openverse

The true test of a hyped food is not whether we enjoyed it once.

It is whether we went back for another and felt genuine disappointment when it was gone. Aldi has turned this experience into a recurring grocery-store drama: curiosity gets the first one into the cart, but regret sends us back for three more.

Read More:

About the Writer

Jenny Milam

The Latest

a man and a woman sitting on a couch
10 Reasons Rising Mental Health Visits Are Good News
Young lady in casual wear lying in comfortable hammock leaned on hands near window and radiator in apartment in afternoon
10 Things to Know About Biphasic Sleep
DuckDuckGo app on phone
9 Reasons DuckDuckGo's Browser is a Game-Changer for YouTube Ad Blocking
Assorted credit cards on a wooden table next to a leaflet with motivational text about financial goals.
10 Credit Card Features That Sound Better Than They Often Are
Young woman painting on an easel in a studio.
9 Ways to Cope with Grieving Someone Still Alive